There’s just something magical about pie. It’s nostalgic, homey, a little bit messy, and my absolute favorite type of dessert! Over the years, I have shared so many incredible pie recipes here on Oh Sweet Basil, but a few of them have earned their place as true fan favorites—the best pie recipes you all make again and again.

This roundup features my most popular pies of all time, from classic fruit pies with buttery, flaky crusts to creamy custard pies and rich holiday favorites. Whether you’re planning your Thanksgiving menu or just craving a slice of something sweet on a Sunday afternoon, these tried-and-true pies deliver every single time.

Classic Fruit Pies

Fruit pies are the heart of homemade pie baking—simple ingredients, bright flavors, and that irresistible blend of tender fruit and flaky crust. These classic fruit pies are some of our most popular recipes because they never go out of style and always taste like home.

The Best Peaches and Cream Pie Recipe

Who doesn’t like Peaches and Cream? Here’s a great way to enjoy this yummy combination in a fabulous pie with our all butter pie crust!

My friend Lisa brought me the most delicious, can’t-stop-eating-this-pie and my life has never been the same. Why haven’t I ever had a simple peaches and cream pie? IT’S SO GOOD! I think the secret is absolutely in the peaches. I know, you thought it would be the cream. But that’s just creamy and wonderful, it’s the peaches that can ruin everything and these peaches are really sweet and perfect! 

Lisa is one of those friends that you love instantly because she’s so real, and love forever because she’s loyal. I adore that, and I adore that no matter if I’m a hot mess or totally on my game she’s not only there, she won’t even notice. I want to be more like that.

Back to peaches and cream though…we are obsessed with the combo! Check out our peaches and cream muffins, peaches and cream crumble bars and peaches and cream overnight oatmeal. Everything about peaches with cream is just perfection!

Recommended Equipment

• Ultragel
• Pie Dish

Before You Begin…

You want to start by making the pie crust, blind baking it and letting it cool completely. If you don’t want to make your own crust, you can grab a store bought crust and bake it according to the instructions on the package.

Ingredients for Peaches and Cream Pie

• Pie Crust: You will need flour, unsalted butter, salt, sugar and ice water to make the pie crust.
• Cream Cheese: I highly recommend using full fat cream cheese. The texture just turns out better.
• Powdered Sugar: Sweetens up the cream layer and balances out the tang of the cream cheese.
• Heavy Cream: Whipping up the cream gives body, fluffiness and creaminess to the cream layer.
• Vanilla: Adds flavor
• Yellow Peaches: You want freestone peaches, like Early Elberta, that are ripe. Remove the pits and slice them. Peeling is optional.
• Sugar: Helps balance the tartness of the peaches. If your peaches seems super sweet, then you can reduce the sugar a little.
• Ultra Gel: Helps thicken the saucy peach layer.
• Water: Helps create a thick syrupy peach layer for the top of the pie.

The measurements for all the ingredients can be fo

Key Lime Pie Recipe

There’s nothing quite like a perfect Key Lime Pie. That graham cracker crust filled with a bright and zippy but totally creamy filling is meant to be your dessert this week. 

THIS IS THE BEST KEY LIME PIE RECIPE EVER!! 

Phew. 

Sometimes you just gotta yell it to make it known. I’ve been making key lime pie since I got married 16 years ago and this is the ultimate recipe. It all started with key lime pie that Cade had while serving a mission for 2 years in Brazil. It’s called Torta de Limão in Brazil and while we adore this recipe for bars, our pie needed to have that Florida key lime vibe so I’ve been testing and testing off and on for years until this year I decided to throw in a little sour cream and bam! Deliciousness is served. 

What Ingredients are Needed for a Classic Key Lime Pie?

This recipe is so simple that it’s dangerous! You only need a few ingredients, and you’ll likely have several of them on hand already. Making this recipe actually reminds me of making my mom’s famous lemon meringue pie. Fresh citrus just makes the best desserts ever! Here is your grocery store list:

• Graham Cracker Crust: graham cracker crumbs, melted butter and sugar
• Sweetened Condensed Milk: gives the pie it’s sweetness and creaminess
• Sour Cream: adds creaminess and tartness
• Lime Zest: flavor, flavor, flavor
• Lime Juice: squeeze your own juice or buy bottled key lime juice, I always recommend fresh!
• Egg Yolks: add so much richness
• Stabilized Whipped Cream: water, gelatin, heavy cream, powdered sugar and vanilla

The measurements for each ingredient can be found in the recipe card below.

Recommended Equipment:

• Pie Pan
• Food Processor
• KitchenAid Mixer
• Citrus Juicer
• Zester

How to Make a Key Lime Pie Recipe

And you thought the ingredients list was nice and easy! Just wait until you see how easy it is to make this pie! Here are the basic steps:

1. Make a graham cracker crust and let it cool.
2. Whisk all the filling ingredients together in a mixing bowl.
3. Pour mixture into the prepared pie crust.
4. Bake and then cool.
5. Serve with whipped cream on top.

All of these steps can be found in the recipe card below.

Ho

Wild Blueberry Pie with Shortbread Crust

This wild blueberry pie is topped with a brown sugar streusel (I know, streusels are life!) and the shortbread crust is so rich and buttery!

I don’t know that there’s a huge benefit to me posting pie recipes every few months. No one seems to love pie exactly like me online. IRL? Yes, because my people are in fact “my people” and they get the pie love. Hence why we are friends. One in particular, Janelle, she just gets me. We would be the best travel-to-eat companions. Obviously when I saw her at a party holding a pie it was the first one I had to try. 

And that was the best idea. 

This is that pie. 

She is the genius that combined lots of wonderful recipes from bloggers across the web to create the ultimate blueberry crumble pie. And in case you even dared to ignore it, the streusel crumble on top is the most glorious element of the show.

Actually, I think Janelle hit gold by going for wild blueberries (most grocery stores now sell them in the freezer department) which transform this pie. This is sure to be one of your new favorite summer desserts!

Ingredients for Blueberry Pie

There are three components to this recipe so it looks like a lot of ingredients but most of them overlap to it’s really just a short list. Here is what you will need:

Shortbread Crust

• Flour: regular all purpose
• Powdered Sugar: all the sweetness without the grainy texture of granulated sugar
• Butter: unsalted is preferred
• Vanilla: adds flavor
• Almond Extract: adds flavor
• Salt: enhances all the flavors

Filling

• Wild Blueberries: you can use frozen if needed
• Lemon Zest and Juice: fresh is best
• Sugar: regular granulated, it balances the tartness of the berries
• Cornaby’s EZ Gel: thickens the filling
• Salt: enhances the sweetness

Streusel Topping

• Flour: all purpose
• Brown Sugar: adds richness and sweetness to the streusel crumble
• Sugar: a little more sweetness
• Salt: cuts the sweetness
• Butter: unsalted is preferred

Optional Glaze

• Powdered Sugar: adds sweetness to balance the acidity of the lemon juice
• Lemon Juice: must be fresh
• Milk: thins out the glaze a little

The measurements for each ingredient can be found in the recipe card at the end of the post.

Read more

Sugared Pear Galette Pie

Juicy thinly sliced pears wrapped in a buttery flaky crust in a rustic style pie called a galette. This Perfect Sugared Pear Galette Pie is 100% the greatest dessert ever, imho.

However, not everyone feels that way, which is totally fine but I was missing it! This last Thanksgiving we enjoyed a glorious meal but since the families aren’t into pie all that much, I really was feeling it. So, my friend Kerri and I decided to have a little gathering 2 days after the holiday but then disaster struck- a barfing kiddo!

Our plans were foiled but I couldn’t get this idea of a pear dessert out of my head. So, Saturday rolled around and I started testing recipes and holy moly, it was inspired! Every single person in my family devoured it and Cade kept saying, forget apple pie, this is my new favorite!

Ingredients for a Pear Galette

When all is said and done, you only need 8 ingredients to make this recipe. I couldn’t believe that when I actually sat down and counted the ingredients…only 8! And most of them you will already have on hand. I’m going to go out on a limb and say that the only thing you’ll need to go to the store for are the pears and candied ginger, unless you’re running low on a pantry staple. Here is what you will need:

Crust

• Flour – just regular all purpose flour
• Sugar – adds a little sweetness to the crust
• Salt – enhances all the flavors
• Unsalted Butter – if you only have salted butter, just omit the salt from the recipe
• Ice Water – get the water as cold as you possible can, it helps the butter stay cold making a flakier crust

Filling

• Butter – adds richness and flavor to the filling
• Pears – I like a combination of Bartlett and Bosc, Anjou also works great
• Sugar – adds sweetness to the filling
• Flour – helps the filling thicken
• Cinnamon – adds that signature fall/holiday flavor
• Candied Ginger – this is the secret weapon, that extra pop of flavor is amazing

Egg Wash

• Egg – whisked well, it helps the crust bake to golden perfection
• Water – thins out the egg wash a little
• Sugar – adds a little sweetness and extra shimmer to the crust

The measurements for each of the ingredients is listed in the recipe card at the end of the post. You can save and/or print the recipe there as well.

Four Important Tips for the Best Pear Galette

There are a few things that make this recipe extra special…

1. The crust. We aren’t going to make a traditional crust, we are going to make a flakier, sheets of pastry dough crust (see section below for more details). This is accomplished by rolling out the butter in long sheets which I read about in a book long ago. Their version took a few hours and too many steps for me, so I’ve shortened things up and made it crazy easy. In fact, if you struggle with a pie crust this is your new best friend.
2. Brown Butter. Need I say more? Head to our chewy pumpkin cookies pos